Views from an Isle seat

11/08/2026

Taken at face value, 1999 seems an unlikely watershed year in the development of Tasmania's cool-climate wine industry. Book-ended by the exceptional 1998 and 2000 vintages, the 1999 harvest came at the end of a very challenging growing season.

Wet and humid during spring, horrendously stormy over Christmas, and alarmingly chilly throughout April, vintage was only made possible on some sites by the arrival of the warmest May in 100 years.

Producers fully immersed in what was going on in their vineyards only just managed to escape the season's powdery and downy mildews, botrytis bunch rot and multiple flights of light brown apple moth.

Others were not so fortunate. 

Image: Mark Smith
Image: Mark Smith

Jim Chatto (pictured) might have been excused for wondering whether he'd have been better off staying in the the Hunter Valley.

"I made wine at Rosevears Estate in the Tamar Valley in 1999," he says.

"It was my first proper winemaking gig. I really fell in love with Tassie Pinot. In my second year of working there, I convinced my boss to sell me some grapes.

"Chatto Wines was born in vintage 2000. We turned 25 last year."

The former kid from Canberra speaks fondly of those early formative years in Tasmania. It's something visitors always take away with them after meeting him on home turf in the Huon Valley.

Those scoring a seat at last month's Chatto Isle Pinot Noir masterclass – during Wine South's Spring in the Vines – will have taken away much more than that. Genial Jim may well be one of Australia's most celebrated winemakers, but his thoughtfully planned and executed tastings are not about celebrity and personal achievements.

They're all about Chatto trying to make sense of his site and his 20 years as a Huon Valley vigneron.

Chatto Isle is both tour de force and voyage of discovery.

"I am still finding my way, you know," he says with genuine self-deprecation.

"I always say that it takes at least 10 years to get your head around a vineyard site.

"Then you need 10 vintages where you can taste 10 different wines and start thinking about those vintages. It probably takes you another 10 years after that to begin to master it, and another 10 again to really make the best wines you possibly can.

"When we first planted our little vineyard here in 2007, I resolved myself to the fact that I probably won't make the best wines off this site. Someone else will. Which is kinda sad but beautiful at the same time…"

Image: Mark Smith
Image: Mark Smith

Chatto and his wife Daisy dedicated six years to finding a suitable site in Tasmania before finally purchasing land at Glaziers Bay. Two years spent making wine at Rosevears – in 1999 and 2000 – had given Chatto a good overview of the State's Pinot Noir landscape.

It had also ruled out the Tamar Valley as his ideal location.

"Our search became a matter of finding a warm spot in a cold place," he explains.

"Right on the edge of what's viticulturally possible. That's where I think you make the best wines."

Chatto was smitten early on by the wine quality and vineyard potential of the Huon Valley. He admired the successes of Eric and Jette Phillips at Elsewhere (Glaziers Bay), Michael and Sharon Vishacki at Panorama (Cradoc), and Terry and Rosemary Bennett at Home Hill (Ranelagh).

A deal was struck when land right next door to Elsewhere came onto the real estate market in 2006. Eight clones of Pinot Noir – 114, 115, 667, 777, G5V15, D5V12, MV6 and Abel – were added to the greenfield site over the following 12 months. 

Behold Chatto Isle.

Dijon selections 114, 115, 667 and 777 provided something of a safety net, typically favouring early-season ripening.

"We only do Pinot Noir," Chatto adds.

"It's my favourite variety. For me, it's the one that best translates the place and the season, and even the person involved. They're the three aspects that make wine really interesting.

"I find it really amazing that you can pick up a well-made wine from a certain site or vineyard – a wine that might even be 50 years old – yet you can recognise where it was grown, the kind of season experienced (whether it was a cool year or a wet year or a warm year), and even who made it.

"I can't think of too many edible products you can do that with, so for me that's part of the magic of wine. It's a bit nerdy but it's quite magical."

Day-to-day management of the couple's new close-planted vineyard on Dillons Road was initially contracted out to local (Sailor Seeks Horse) vignerons Paul and Gilli Lipscombe.

Chatto, meanwhile, continued to fulfil key winemaking roles in the Hunter Valley.

The first two harvests from the 1.4ha passion project contributed to white-labelled sub-regional blends called Chatto Huon Valley Pinot Noir. (Recent blends are now labelled Lutruwita.)

The first single vineyard wine from estate plantings was produced in 2014.

Isle Pinot Noir was given striking black livery to distinguish it from its blended sibling.

"We moved back here from the Hunter in 2017," Chatto told his 18 masterclass guests.

"This was the first year our wine was made on site. Previously we had shipped the fruit up to the Hunter Valley, where the winemaking occurred.

"We've been running the vineyard organically ever since 2017 – avoiding systemic sprays, mulching under vines, doing brush cutting by hand. It's a lot of work."

No amount of fastidious, cool-climate viticulture could save the Huon Valley from the near total loss of its 2019 vintage, however. Prolonged summer bushfire activity not only burnt out 63,000ha of native forests, it also rendered vineyard crops unsuitable for winemaking due to smoke taint.

Vale 2019 Chatto Isle. 

"A couple of wineries tried and they probably regretted that because the wines have a really smoky character," Chatto says.

"It's not that pleasant smoked cheese or smoked chicken sort of character. It's acrid ashtray. You taste it on your back palate. It's bitter, and it's not pleasant. It also gets worse as the wine ages.

"The irony is the bunches on our vines in 2019 looked perfectly healthy."

Image: Supplied
Image: Supplied

Thanks to the extraordinary generosity of industry friends in the north of the State – at Marion's Vineyard and Kreglinger Wine Estates – the tiny family business was able to purchase small volumes of 2019 Pinot Noir from the Tamar Valley and Pipers Brook, and cling on to its dreams.

Masterclass participants were thus able to taste and assess six vintages of Isle Pinot Noir spanning 12 years – 2014, 2016, 2018, 2020, 2022 and 2024.

Wines were presented in pairs and accompanied by an invaluable 'ready reckoner' prepared by Chatto. The highly informative little spreadsheet detailed relevant growing conditions across each season climate, Isle harvest dates and vineyard crop production.

Bureau of Meteorology's ENSO data – denoting changes in global weather patterns between El Niño (warm/dry) and La Niña (cool/wet) phases – provided additional food for thought.

Here's a summary of observations raised by Chatto and masterclass participants:

Bracket 1: 2014 Chatto Isle Pinot Noir and 2016 Chatto Isle Pinot Noir

  • Cool, wet weather in late November/early December disturbed flowering and fruit set leading up to the 2014 vintage. Harvest took place over Easter. The resulting mix of small and large berries (referred to as 'hen and chicken') contributed some raisiny characters to the finished wine.
  • "The smallest crop we've ever had – 1.93 tonnes. (One tonne produces approx 900 bottles.)  The 2014 has a nice savoury lushness to it and silky tannins. Everybody loved that richness when it was a young wine but it's a style that generally doesn't age well. It's ageing a little more quickly than I think we'll see with the 2016."
  • "Vintage 2016 produced a record crop in Tasmania and remains one of our biggest –  6.43 tonnes. It was harvested just after Easter.  Warm year, ripe fruit. Lighter-bodied than the 2014. More acidity."
  • "These wines are chameleon-like. They change in the glass. As they get air, they change. I imagine if you sit for another hour, the '14 will start to fade, and the '16 will open up a bit more."

Bracket 2: 2018 Chatto Isle Pinot Noir and 2020 Chatto Isle Pinot Noir

  • "This is kinda like the bracket before. One was a warm year with good flowering and a good crop, and one was the opposite... So the 2018's a bit more like the 2016, while the 2020's a lot more like the 2014's growing season. I like the '18 a lot. Spring was warm, then our weather was very average all the way through to harvest. A really good season. The wine's nice and spicy too…. One of my favourites. I've loved it since the day we bottled it. Since the day we picked it."
  • "In the warmer years – where the wine can tend to be a bit big and butch – I use some whole bunch fermentation just to try to refine it a bit, to add some spice and cut back on the ripe fruit characters. In the cooler years, you're already on the edge of some of those herbal flavours so then I back it right off. The 2018 was nearly 40 percent whole bunch. It's not a recipe, it's just a feeling, according to the harvest. It's one of the tools you have in your winemaking kitbag."
  • "Vintage 2020 had some cooler parts, especially during flowering and fruit set. We also had a massive rain event here in the valley. There's not much whole bunch in the winemaking. Autumn rainfall was 172% of average. Our 2020 wine avoided much of that. We picked and the next we had 100mm of rain. We're generally the earliest vineyard in the Huon."
  • "The crop level wasn't quite as low as 2014 but it was a very dry summer. It also came after the bushfire year of 2019. Anecdotally, it appears you get a reduced crop after a significant smoke event. But I don't know whether it was the season or the smoke that caused the low crop.
  • "The big difference between the 2022 and the 2014 wines is that we had our sorting machine that now allows us to separate out 99 percent of those little raisins from the dry weather conditions. So we've kept more brightness, freshness in the 2020 wine. I think it's a better wine, even though 2014 was probably received much better as a young wine than the 2020."

Image: Mark Smith
Image: Mark Smith

Bracket 3: 2022 Chatto Isle Pinot Noir and 2024 Chatto Isle Pinot Noir

  • "These are two of my favourite wines. I don't know if they're better vintages, or whether I've just got better at understanding how to make the wine. Seasonally they were very similar years."
  • "Both of these were picked pretty much bang-on Easter. In 2024, Easter was very early, in late March. Easter was around two weeks later in 2022. It doesn't seem to matter much whether Easter comes early or late, our fruit is generally ripe and ready for picking then."
  • "I reckon vintage 2024 is a great vintage right across Tassie. Everyone in Tassie made a great '24. Vintage 2022 was probably better in the south than in the north. Some years are like that."
  • "Vintage 2024 – and maybe 2021 and 2017 in recent memory – they're the vintages where everyone in Tassie made a great Pinot. Awesome, almost regardless of brand."
  • "The 2024 looks so young there in the glass. The 2022 is already looking like a complete wine to me. It's got spice, it's got sandalwood, it's got small red fruits. It's got good texture and is pretty seamless on the palate."
  • "The 2024 looks a bit callow in a sense but its only crime is that it's guilty of being too young at the moment. I can see its potential. It's got an intensity about it that I really love."

My favourites? Vintages 2022, 2024 and 2018. Sadly, all sold out.

The good news is that the 2025s from Chatto Wines are also very smart indeed. 

I particularly like the 2025 Intrigue Pinot Noir, which was carefully crafted from all eight Pinot Noir clones in the Isle Vineyard.

Be sure to join the Chatto Wines mailing list. That will allow you to be front and centre whenever the next masterclass comes around. Last month's offered superb value at $50 per person.

Disclosure: Mark Smith was a paying guest at October's Chatto Isle Masterclass.

www.chattowines.com

Last page update: 10 November 2026